Huge instagram photo because S'MORES CRISPIES! by @kelsamur
I've been pondering, plotting, pouring over recipes, and generally bothering MJ constantly about different ideas and stratagems relating to the great quest to create a S'Mores Crispy for the past few days.
Golden Grahams or real graham crackers?
Milk or dark chocolate? Or BOTH?
Yes, definitely both.
How to best get toasty marshmallow flavor?
Marshmallow fluff for softer, gooeier crispies?
Should I toss in some of those marshmallow bits that are usually in hot chocolate? Sure, why not.
All of that.
I think the name pretty much says it all, but just in case you want a definition for S'mores Crispy Treats, this new dessert hybrid blends the genius combination of toasted marshmallows, melty chocolate, and graham crackers with an extra ooey gooey rice crispy. I had high hopes for this concoction, and this blend of recipes did not disappoint. In fact, my triumph was so great that I spent a large part of the evening yelling "S'MORES CRISPY!" at random intervals. Sorry neighbors. It was even the last thing I whispered to my husband before I fell asleep. He knows it means love.
Late night snack @kelsamur
I think these treats might have the potential to trump the Cronut (TM) for next hybrid thing–no disrespect to Mr. Ansel, who is truly a genius and shockingly thin. But I don't even want to spare the time to wait in that line much less the 3+ days it would take me to make one. Ain't nobody got time for that!
But this recipe takes about thirty minutes, and you don't even have to wait for the marshmallow and chocolate-laden squares to cool before you dive right in. In fact, I suggest you don't. Get a stack of napkins and go crazy.
S'Mores Crispy Treats
What really sets these glammed-up rice crispies apart from other recipes are two simple extra steps: 1) adding a layer of oven-toasted marshmallows, and 2) browning the butter, as inspired by Smitten Kitchen. Both take just a few extra minutes, but return huge dividends in the flavor department. (Can you tell I married a banker?)
The oven-toasting method was actually a happy accident; I was working off a milkshake recipe that suggested using your oven's broiler to get toasty marshmallows sin campfire, but I do not trust my broiler. It's more temperamental than spring in NYC. Or Idaho. But I discovered that baking the marshmallows turns them into a lovely sheet of toasty goodness, which you can then layer in your rice crispy treats. You can also break them into small pieces once they've cooled, which I did with about half the pan, intending to mix the toasted 'mallows throughout. But it gets a bit sticky and next time around, I'll just do a double layer in the middle, as suggested below. Be sure to cover your baking sheet with a layer of parchment so you can magically lift off the entire sheet of marshmallows. Ooooooh.
Makes an 8x8 pan of very thick bars, or a 9x13 with a single layer of marshmallows in the middle
6 tblsp. butter
1 7.5 oz jar marshmallow fluff
5 oz. (half a bag) jumbo marshmallows
3 cups crisp rice cereal
6 graham crackers
3/4 cup milk chocolate chips
heaping 1/4 cup dark or semi-sweet chocolate chips
1 tsp. vanilla
1/2 tsp. salt, preferably kosher
1/3 cup marshmallow bits (optional)
about 20 to 24 large marshmallows, for toasting
1. Preheat oven to 375° F. Line a baking sheet with parchment paper. Scatter 20 to 24 large marshmallows evenly across baking sheet. You might want to toss on a few extra, for snacking. Bake until puffed and light golden brown.
At the moment, I can not tell you precisely how long this takes, because while baking, I was distracted by a burrito that needed eating. This takes about 10 minutes, depending on your oven—keep a close watch, because the space between golden perfection and charred is not a big space. Set toasted marshmallows aside to cool. Grease an 8x8 or 9x13 pan with a light coat of cooking spray or butter; set aside.
2. Measure crisp rice cereal into a large bowl with marshmallow bits, if using. With your hands, break graham crackers into small pieces (no bigger than a quarter) over the bowl. Stir to combine. Usually, I skip these "mix the dry ingredients" steps, because I'm a rebel. But this step will make adding the cereal and cookie bits to the marshmallow while it's still soft much easier. BONUS: Using a really big pan for the melting the butter and marshmallows means you can pour everything else in there later, then only clean up one sticky item.
3. In a large (5 qt or bigger) pan, melt butter over medium low heat, stirring often and scrapping any brown bits from the bottom of the pan with a wooden spoon or a stiff heat proof spatula. The butter will melt slowly, then begin to foam and brown. As soon as it begins to brown and smell nutty, turn off the heat and add marshmallow fluff, 5 oz marshmallows, salt, and vanilla. Stir until combined and just a few small marshmallow lumps remain. Pour in cereal and graham cracker blend, and stir until well combined. Sprinkle with 1/2 cup milk chocolate chips and all dark or semi-sweet chips. Stir until just combined–-more chocolate will be concentrated in some areas and that's okay.
4. While still hot, press half of the mixture into greased pan. Top with reserved 1/4 cup of milk chocolate chips (feel free to use more if making a 9x13. I don't think anyone will mind). Peel cooled toasted marshmallows off parchment and layer them across the top of the chocolate chips, breaking the marshmallows apart as needed to fit pan; they will be slightly crisp and break apart easily. For an 8x8, you should have enough marshmallows for a double layer. Press remaining half of marshmallowy rice crispy and graham goodness over the toasted marshmallow layer, packing down to bind layers together.
These are awesome while still warm. And you look good with chocolate all over your face.
I would assume they will keep well in an airtight container for a few days, but it doesn't look like I'll be able to verify that anytime soon.